From: Bill Fiess
Sent: Nov 14, 2008 3:54 PM
To: Hodges Zane
Subject: Relationship between Upper Room Discourse and the Epistle of First John

 

Hi Zane,

 

I hope that you have had a good week.  Here is a brief question concerning the Upper Room Discourse and the Epistle of First John:

  • Is it correct to think of First John as an expansion of the Upper Room Discourse or even as based on the Upper Room Discourse?

I think that I have heard this idea expressed but it does not seem to me to be correct. There does seem to be some similar material in First John and the Upper Room Discourse however [such as the imperative of love and abiding in Christ etc.].

 

Thanks, as always, for your help in the Word of God.

 

Bill


From: Zane Hodges

Date: 11/18/2008 11:12:24 AM

To: Bill Fiess

Subject: Re: Relationship between Upper Room Discourse and the Epistle of First John

 

Bill,

I think the answer is no to both parts of your question.

Zane